Real Food, Real Portions, Real Montclair
Sofia's Pizzeria has been feeding Montclair from a small corner of Orange Road — honest portions, real ingredients, and a kitchen that doesn't know how to play it safe.
Sofia's Pizzeria | Our Story
A Neighborhood Spot Worth Knowing
Sofia's sits on Orange Road in the heart of Montclair — where regulars get greeted by name and newcomers leave feeling like they've been coming for years.
The Pizza Comes First
New York crust, good sauce, the kind of cheese pull that earns a reputation. Sicilian, Grandma, Drunken Grandma, deep dish, and build-your-own — slices ready all day.
Beyond the Pizza Box
Birria tacos, shrimp pasta, Frutti di Mare, chicken parm, Penne Vodka deep dish — the kitchen runs wider than you'd expect.
The People Behind the Counter
The team knows their regulars, moves fast, and takes the food seriously — the kind of place that brings your order out to the car on a cold night.
Enough for Everyone
Four family packages from $31 to $118 — pizzas, wings, and drinks bundled so weeknight dinner is one decision, not three.
